HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 06.l
Date: Item No.
Resolution Approving Multiyear Agreement and 2020 Insurance Rates with HealthPartners
Proposed Action
Staff recommends adoption of the following motion: Move to approve Multiyear Health Plan Agreement
with HealthPartners, Inc. for the 2020 health and dental insurance rates.
Overview
NFP, the City’s insurance broker, recently accepted proposals for health, dental and vision insurance. In
August, NFP met with the Insurance Committee to review the results for the RFP process and 2020
insurance rates. It was recommended that the City continue with HealthPartners for both health and
dental insurance. HealthPartners matched the current plan designs and offered an overall 5.85% decrease
in premium rates for health insurance and a rate cap of not to exceed 9% for 2021 (please note, this
doesn’t include administrative costs, taxes, and ACA assessments). HealthPartners also offered a 3.5%
decrease for dental insurance for 2020 and a rate cap of not to exceed 4% for 2021 and 2022.
The City’s Personnel Committee has reviewed HealthPartners proposal and recommends agreement with
HealthPartners. The HealthPartners Multiyear Health Plan Agreement has also been reviewed by our City
Attorney.
Primary Issues to Consider
• What value is provided with HealthPartners’ Multiyear Health Plan Agreement?
Entering into a two agreement with HealthPartners will bring consistency and predictability
to the costs of providing health insurance for our employees and their families.
• What are the health and dental plan designs?
• How is the cost share determined?
Supporting Information
• 2020 Health and Dental Insurance Information
• Resolution approving Multiyear Health Plan Agreement and Health and Dental Insurance
rates for 2020.
• HealthPartners Multiyear Health Plan Agreement
Financial Impact: $ Budgeted: Y☒ N☐ Source:
Related Documents: (CIP, ERP, etc.):
Envision Lakeville Community Values: Good Value for Public Services
Report Completed by: Tammy Schutta, Human Resources Manager
September 16, 2019
General Fund
CITY OF LAKEVILLE
RESOLUTION NO. ____
Resolution Approving Employee Health and Dental Insurance Rates for 2020
WHEREAS, the City Council will establish insurance plans that will be provided; and
WHEREAS, the City Council will establish the costs the City will pay for employee and
dependent coverage under City group health and dental insurance programs; and
WHEREAS, the City Council chooses to promote employee wellness;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED the City Council of the City of Lakeville approves a
Multiyear agreement with HealthPartners to bring consistency and predictability to the costs of
providing health insurance for our employees and their families; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the following monthly cost responsibility is approved for the
HealthPartners health insurance plans (A) and Health Partners dental insurance plan (B)
effective January 1, 2020:
A. Health Ins. MONTHLY PREMIUM COSTS
Employee Employer Total Premium VEBA/HSA Funds
High Deductible/VEBA
Employee 49.25 557.19 606.44 160.00
EE + Child(ren) 473.59 736.95 1210.54 185.00
EE + Spouse 506.23 800.03 1306.26 185.00
Family 593.11 1002.43 1595.54 205.00
High Deductible/HSA
Employee 0.00 557.19 557.19 160.00
EE + Child(ren) 375.28 736.95 1112.23 185.00
EE + Spouse 400.15 800.03 1200.18 185.00
Family 463.54 1002.43 1465.97 205.00
The 2020 VEBA and HSA funding will be deposited in two installments. The first six months of
funding will be deposited in January and the second six months of funding will be deposited in
July. Deposits for new employees will be prorated.
ADOPTED by the Lakeville City Council this 16th day of September 2019
______________________________
Douglas P. Anderson, Mayor
_________________________________
Charlene Friedges, City Clerk
B. Dental Ins. MONTHLY PREMIUM COSTS
Employee Employer Total Premium
Employee 0.00 49.75 49.75
EE + 1 40.04 49.75 89.79
Family 97.74 49.75 147.49
2020 Health and Dental Insurance Information
What bids were received for health insurance?
Bids were received from HealthPartners (incumbent), Allina Aetna, Blue Cross/Blue Shield, Medica and
United HealthCare.
HealthPartners matched current plans designs and offered an overall 5.85 decrease in premium from
current. HealthPartners also offered a rate cap of 9% for 2021 and wellness credits for 2020 and 2021
equally approximately $7,000 each year.
What are the 2020 health plan designs?
• High deductible HRA/VEBA (57 employees currently enrolled)
• High deductible HSA (141 employees currently enrolled)
Annual Deductible – In Network
• HRA/VEBA deductibles are $2,500 per person and $5,000 per family
• HSA deductibles are $2,800 per person and $5,600 per family
Annual Out-of-Pocket Max – In Network
• HRA/VEBA maximum is $3,500 per person and $6,000 per family
• HSA maximum is $3,800 per person and $6,400 per family
The employee will pay an additional 20% of cost of care after the annual deductible is met until they
meet the out-of-pocket maximum.
Prescription Drugs – Formulary
• HRA/VEBA requires a co-pay of $15 for generic, $30 for brand and $60 for non-preferred drugs.
• HSA does not include prescription drug coverage until after the deductible is met.
Cost share
The base plan (HSA) provides minimum essential coverage at the lowest cost; therefore, rates are
determined off of this plan. Employer premiums are established by providing 100% of the single
coverage and splitting the cost of the decrease with employees for the coverage tiers that include
spouse and/or dependent. Once these employer dollar values are established, they are applied to the
HRA/VEBA plan.
What is the 2020 dental plan design?
The City contributes 100% of the cost for single coverage. Any additional costs for dependents are
paid by the employee. The plan provides up to $1,500 of coverage for in-network expenses each as
follows:
• Diagnostic and preventive – paid at 100%
• Basic services – paid at 80%
• Crowns – paid at 50%
9/6/19 Page 1 of 5
Multiyear Health Plan Agreement
This AGREEMENT is made by and between HealthPartners, Inc. a Minnesota nonprofit
corporation (“HealthPartners”) and City of Lakeville (“Client”), together “the Parties”, and is effective
as of January 1, 2020 (“Effective Date”) (“the Agreement”).
RECITALS
WHEREAS, the Parties desire to enter into a mutually beneficial long term relationship which will
bring stability and predictability to the costs of providing high quality health care benefits to the Client’s
employees and dependents, and
WHEREAS, Client has released a request for proposal contemplating a multi-year agreement and
HealthPartners has responded to such request (“Proposal”), and
WHEREAS, in exchange for such a long term relationship, HealthPartners is willing to offer
guaranteed rates to Client and Client is willing to remain contracted with HealthPartners for the term of
the Agreement and
WHEREAS, each Party has independently determined that this Agreement is in its best interests
and each Party is committed to a successful implementation of the terms and conditions expressed in this
Agreement;
NOW, THEREFORE, for good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which
are hereby acknowledged, the Parties hereby agree as follows;
ARTICLE 1
HEALTHPARTNERS DUTIES
1.1 Plan Offering. HealthPartners shall provide for the time period specified (“Plan Years”), the
health plan coverage (“Product” or “Products”) as described in the HealthPartners Proposal of
September 6, 2019 under the terms of this Agreement. In the event a particular Product is no
longer offered, a comparable Product in terms of benefit design will be offered upon renewal with
appropriate actuarial values of any benefit changes applied to the Guaranteed Rates as described
in Section 1.2.
1.2 Guaranteed Rates. HealthPartners guarantees, for the Plan Years described in the Proposal, the
rates for all Products as follows, or the standard HealthPartners renewal calculation for all
Products, whichever is more favorable to Client:
Table 1 Guaranteed Rates
Plan Year Plan Year
2020 2021
$2800-80% HSA
Single $557.19 $607.34
Single+Sp $1,200.18 $1,308.20
Single+Ch(ren) $1,112.23 $1,212.33
Family $1,465.97 $1,597.91
9/6/19 Page 2 of 5
$2500-80% HRA
Single $606.44 $661.02
Single+Sp $1,306.26 $1,423.82
Single+Ch(ren) $1,210.54 $1,319.49
Family $1,595.54 $1,739.14
1.3 Adjustments. Notwithstanding the above, the following exceptions and adjustments apply to the
Guaranteed Rates described in Section 1.2:
a. The actuarial value of any new or increased premium taxes, industry fees, excise taxes,
research fees, or any other government or regulatory assessments, or other taxes as a result of
any change in law or regulation, including but not limited to, the Affordable Care Act of 2010
or other state or federal health care reform legislation, shall result in a corresponding change
to the Guaranteed Rates. The Guaranteed Rates and the Standard Rates do not include the
excise tax on high cost health plans under section 49801 of the Internal Revenue Code (“the
Cadillac Tax” effective January 1, 2018, deferred until 2022); all amounts due under the
Cadillac Tax are payable by Client in addition to Product rates.
b. The actuarial value of any new or increased eligibility or benefit mandated by law or
regulation or other change to Product features required by law shall result in a corresponding
change to the Guaranteed Rates.
c. Any enrollment change of 10% or more from initial enrollment, whether due to expansion,
merger, acquisition, sale, reduction in force or other reason, may result in a revision to the
Guaranteed Rates, at the sole discretion of HealthPartners.
1.4 Renewals. HealthPartners shall release a standard renewal calculation prior to the end of each
Plan Year.
ARTICLE II
CLIENT DUTIES
2.1 Sole Carrier. Client shall remain directly contracted with HealthPartners on a fully insured basis
as the sole carrier offered to any and all Client employees for any medical benefit offering, during
the term of this Agreement.
2.2 Master Group Contract. This Agreement is subject to all the terms and conditions of the fully
insured Master Group Contract issued separately upon acceptance of the Client’s application for
coverage.
2.3 Contribution and Participation. Client shall:
a. maintain the current employer premium and fund contribution strategy,
b. maintain the current Product offerings. Plans with a benefit value within 5% of the current
plan or plans’ benefit value (determined using HealthPartners' value calculator) satisfy this
Product maintenance requirement. Plan changes with a benefit value difference of 5% or less
will be rated based on the value of such benefit change,
c. meet the current participation guidelines, and
d. fulfill HealthPartners coverage requirements of the Master Group Contract regarding
Product offerings.
2.4 Authority. Client represents and warrants that it has full authority under law and its governance
requirements to enter into this Agreement. By executing this Agreement below, Client intends for
HealthPartners to rely on the authority of the signatory to this Agreement to bind the Client to the
terms of this Agreement.
9/6/19 Page 3 of 5
ARTICLE III
TERM, TERMINATION AND BREACH
3.1 Term. This Agreement applies to the Plan Years as shown in Section 1.2, for a total Guaranteed
Rate period of 24 months.
3.2 Early Termination or Breach. In the event Client terminates this Agreement prior to the
completion of the last Plan Year or fails to comply with any of the terms of this Agreement or the
Master Group Contract described in Section 2.3, Client shall pay to HealthPartners the Rate
Differentials as shown in Table 3 (i.e., the difference between the Guaranteed Rates of Table 1
and the Standard Rates of Table 2), times the last month’s enrollment times the number of months
remaining to the completion of the last Plan Year.
Table 2 Standard Rates
Plan Year Plan Year
2020 2021
$2800-80% HSA
Single $601.77 $655.93
Single+Sp $1,296.19 $1,412.86
Single+Ch(ren) $1,201.21 $1,309.32
Family $1,583.25 $1,725.74
$2500-80% HRA
Single $654.96 $713.90
Single+Sp $1,410.76 $1,537.73
Single+Ch(ren) $1,307.38 $1,425.05
Family $1,723.18 $1,878.27
Table 3 Rate Differentials
Plan Year Plan Year
2020 2021
$2800-80% HSA
Single $44.58 $48.59
Single+Sp $96.01 $104.66
Single+Ch(ren) $88.98 $96.99
Family $117.28 $127.83
$2500-80% HRA
Single $48.52 $52.88
Single+Sp $104.50 $113.91
Single+Ch(ren) $96.84 $105.56
Family $127.64 $139.13
9/6/19 Page 4 of 5
3.3 Group Size. In the event federal or state law requires community rating for groups of a particular
size and Client’s group size falls within such parameters, upon the effective date of such change
as applied to Client, this Agreement will be terminated and appropriate replacement products and
rates will be offered, in accordance with current law.
3.4 Waiver. In the event state or federal law requires the Client to terminate this Agreement,
HealthPartners may waive some or all of the Rate Differentials, in its sole discretion.
ARTICLE IV
THIRD PARTIES
4.1 Client Due Diligence. Client has received advice and counsel from a third party consultant,
which the Client separately selected and retained, as part of its due diligence in the process of
selecting a carrier for the Plan Years covered in this Agreement. Client acknowledges that such
third party consultant is not an agent of HealthPartners and is an independent advisor not selected
by HealthPartners.
ARTICLE V
MISCELLANEOUS
5.1 Governing Law, Jurisdiction, and Venue: This Agreement shall be governed by and interpreted
under Minnesota law. Any lawsuit arising directly or indirectly out of this Agreement shall be
brought in a court of competent jurisdiction located in the state of Minnesota.
9/6/19 Page 5 of 5
Accepted and agreed to, with an Effective Date as noted first above:
HealthPartners, Inc.
_______________________________________
Signature Date
Douglas N. Smith
Senior Vice President, Health Solutions, Sales &
Account Service
City of Lakeville
_______________________________________
Signature Date
_______________________________________
Name
Title