HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-16-98 CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETINt~
MARCH 16, 1998
The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m. by Mayor Zaun. The pledge of
allegiance to the flag was given..
Roll call was taken. Present: Councilmembers Ryan, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg
and Mayor. Zaun.
Also present: R. Knutson, City Attorney; B. Erickson, City Administrator; K.
Nelson, City Engineer; M. Sobota, Community & Economic Development
Director; D. Feller, Finance Director; S. Michaud, Parks & Recreation Director;
D. Martens, Chief of Police; 'D. Morey, Planner, F. Dempsey, Associate
Planner; J. Hennen, Administrative Assistant; C. Friedges, City Clerk.
MINUTES
The minutes. of the March 2, 1998, City Council meeting and the February 10,
1998, Council work session were approved as presented.
STAFF ANNOUNCEMENTS
ATTORNEY: None
ENGINEER: None
ADMINISTRATOR: Mr. Erickson asked the Council to consider, under New
Business, a draft letter proposed to be sent to the Minnesota Public Utilities
Commission opposing .the removal of more than 800 Lakeville residents from
the 612 area code.
CHIEF OF POLICE: Chief Martens presented the February, 1998, Police
Department monthly report.
PARKS & RECREATION DIRECTOR: Mr. Michaud. presented the 1997 Parks
& Recreation Department annual report.
PRESENTATI®NS/INTRODUCTIONS
Mayor Zaun presented a plaque to Carah Drews for her service to the- City of
• Lakeville: as a member of the Environmental Affairs Committee.
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 2
CITIZENS' COMMENTS None
CONSENT AGENDA
Councilmembers removed Items 7a, 7g, 7m and 7q from the consent agenda.
98.56 .Motion was made by Holberg, seconded by Mulvihill to approve the consent
agenda items as follows:
a. (Removed from consent agenda.)
b. Receive February Investment Report.
c. Receive minutes of the following advisory committee meetings:
Environmental Affairs Committee, February 17th, February 24th and
March 3rd
Planning Commission, February 19th and March 5th
Economic Development Commission, February 24th
Ames Ice Arena Committee, February 25th
Parks & Recreation Committee, March 4th
d. Resolution No. 98-36 approving plans and specifications and setting a bid
date for Improvement Projects 97-5, 98-2, 96-4 and 97-20.
e. Resolution No. 98-37 approving plans and specifications and setting a bid.
date for playground equipment.
f. Agreement with Metropolitan Regional Arts Council
g. (Removed from consent agenda.)
h. Mechanical amusement device license for Lakeville Theatre, 20653
Keokuk Avenue.
i. Resolution No. 98-38 appointing members to the. Employee Position
Evaluation Committee.
j. Resolution No. 98-39 accepting donation to the DARE Program from First
National Bank of Monticello, Lakeville Branch.
k. .Farm lease with Michael Streiff, Jr.
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 3
I. Resolution No. 98-40 extending park hours for special events at Antlers
Park and Ritter Farm Park.
m. (Removed from consent agenda.)
n. Final acceptance of public utilities and road improvements, Muller
Theatres.
o. Resolution No. 98-41 designating 170th Street from Flagstaff Avenue to
Pilot Knob Road (formerly County Road 58) as a municipal state aid
roadway.
p. Agreement with Lakeville Five, Inc. and Aurora Investments for Heritage
Commons.
q. (Removed from consent agenda..)
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg.
ITEM 8
Mr. Brad Determan, representing Hearth Technologies, Inc.., requested Council
approval of a conditional use permit and redevelopment contract to allow the
construction of a Heat-N-Glo corporate headquarters/research and
development facility in Fairfield Business Campus.
Mr. Sobota explained that the proposed 80,232 square foot Heat-N-GIo
corporate headquarters facility will house corporate administrative offices, sales
and marketing, and design/engineering functions, including product and
prototype development and testing. Heat-N-GIo representatives are also
planning for the possibility of a future retail sales area within their corporate
headquarters facility. He explained that Heat-N-GIo has applied for tax
increment financing to allow them to locate in Fairfield Business Campus. Staff
has negotiated a redevelopment contract with Heat-N-GIo that includes
provisions for the creation of at least 20 new jobs by December 31, 2000. The
City will be responsible for the extension of Kensington Boulevard in the future
when the property to the north of Fairfield Business Campus develops. The
project has been reviewed by the Fairfield Business Campus Property Owners
Association, who found the plans consistent with the covenants for Fairfield
Business Campus.
CITY. OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 4
Mr. Morey explained that because of the multitude of uses involved with the
Heat-N-Glo facility and Business Campus District zoning., a conditional use
permit is required for this project. The conditional use permit addresses the
potential future expansion of the facility. Mr. Morey provided an overview of
the performance standards reviewed by City staff and by the Planning
Commission, including parking, driveway access, landscaping and signage.
The Planning Commission unanimously recommended approval. Revised
plans were submitted based upon recommendations given in the planning and
engineering reports. Staff recommends approval of the conditional use permit
and redevelopment contract.
Councilmember Holberg asked if this type of business is subject to any
Pollution Control Agency regulations. Mr. Determan stated they are; however,
what they do is essentially construct prototypes and burn and test them in
applications similar to what is done in a residential setting.
Councilmember Ryan asked about the value of the land with regard to tax
increment financing. Mr. Sobota stated the approximate value of the land is $1
per square foot, which includes streets, sewer, water and storm sewer. He
explained that the storm. sewer area charge will be paid by tax increment; and
the developer will pay the park dedication fee. Taxes that are generated by the
80,000 square foot building will. go to pay the bonds that were sold to develop
the property.
..Councilmember Ryan asked what the risks are to the City with regard to tax
increment financing. Mr. Sobota explained that the risks for the City were
defined when the district was created. It is now a matter of getting the tenants
into the campus to gef the tax base up to pay for the bonds. He pointed out
that with this project and the proposed TMl project, the City will be ahead of
schedule for repayment of the bonds.
Councilmember Ryan asked what the City's equity position in the land would
be if a business in Fairfield Business Campus would -:run across hard times.
Mr. Knutson stated it depends on when the hard times occur. A letter of credit
would cover initial hard times. If the building would burn down, insurance
would cover it. If the property owners don't pay their taxes, a personal
guarantee is built into the agreement whereby the building would be sold and
someone else would take over operation, thus generating taxes. He pointed
out that the chances of the property going tax forfeit are next to zero.
98.57 Motion was made by Mulvihill, seconded by Holberg to receive the Planning
Commission's Findings of Fact and Recommendation and approve a
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
.PAGE 5
conditional use permit and redevelopment contract for Hearth Technologies,
Inc. to allow construction of a Heat-N-Glo light. manufacturing, warehousing,
storage and indoor limited retail sales on property located on Lot 1, Block 1,
Fairfield Business Campus Addition.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan.
ITEM 9
Gary Lussier and Steve Nelson, representing Technical Methods, Inc.,
requested Council approvaFof a conditional use permit :and redevelopment
contract to allow the construction of a corporate headquarters, light
manufacturing and warehouse facility in Fairfield Business Campus.
Mr. Sobota provided an overview of the proposal by Technical Methods, Inc..
(TMI) for construction of a 24,960 square foot corporate. headquarters,
manufacturing, warehouse building. He explained that TMI provides computer-
aided design, manufacturing services and pattern making/prototype production
for aerospace and commercial applications. TMI has applied for tax increment
financing to allow them to locate in Fairfield Business Campus. Staff has
negotiated a redevelopment contract with TMI that includes provisions for the
creation of at least 10 new jobs and a $1 million minimum valuation. TMI will
be assessed the storm sewer area charge, and the park dedication fee will be
paid in cash at the time of closing on the land.. The City will be responsible for
the future extension of Kensington Boulevard to the north. The Fairfield
Business Campus Property Owners Association has.. reviewed the proposed
plans for architectural compliance with the covenants for Fairfield Business
Campus.
Mr. Morey stated the TMI development will consist of 60% green space with the
initial development. The developer will enter into a parking deferment
development contract guaranteeing that the required number of parking spaces
will be constructed if the site parking demand exceeds supply. The driveway
access is located at the south boundary of the site so that a shared driveway
can be constructed when Itron expands or another business develops to the
south. The developer will submit a $5,000 security to guarantee installation of
the approved landscaping. There will be one monument sign on the site and
one wall sign on the front of the building. Staff recommends. approval of the
conditional use permit and redevelopment contract.
City Engineer Keith Nelson explained that staff negotiated a change order with
S Brown & Cris for the extension of sanitary sewer and water services to serve
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 6
the TMI site. This lot requires utility services at this time due to the final platting
and lot splits of Fairfield Business Campus 2nd Addition occurring after the
initial construction of Kensington Boulevard. Funding for the proposed change
order will be from the. Fairfield Business Campus Tax Increment Financing
District.
Councilmember Sindt asked if there will be truck traffic to this site. Mr. Lussier
stated there will be very little truck traffic.
98.58 Motion was made by Holberg, seconded by Sindt to receive the Planning
Commission's Findings of Fact and Recommendation and approve a
conditional use permit and redevelopment contract for Technical Methods, Inc.
to allow the. construction of a manufacturing/warehouse building on Lot 3, Block
1, Fairfield Business Campus 2nd Addition; and approve Change Order No. 2
with Brown & Cris, Inc.,lmprovement Project 97-11, for the construction of
water main, sanitary sewer and water services on Kensington Boulevard to
serve Lot 3, Block 1, Fairfield Business Campus 2nd Addition.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan, Zaun.
ITEMS 10-11
Finance Director Dennis Feller presented a resolution authorizing the issuance
and sale of $2,495,000 General Obligation Tax Increment Bonds. He explained.
that the City issued general obligation temporary tax increment bonds in 1995
to finance Fairfield Business Campus improvements. The proposed 1998 bond.
issue will refinance the $2,401,700 balloon payment on the temporary bonds.
Mr. Feller explained that increment from the Fairfield. Business Campus, along
with interest on investments for the debt service funds, is adequate to pay all of
the debt service, plus the obligations for the TMI and Hearth Technologies
projects and the future extension of Kensington Boulevard. Excess increments
will be available which the City Council has the .prerogative to use at some
future date by either calling the bonds or applying them toward other eligible
projects, such as the County Road 70 bridge.
Mr. Feller also presented a resolution authorizing the issuance and sale of
$515,000 General Obligation Equipment Certificates of indebtedness. He
explained that the proposed certificates of indebtedness will mature over a five
year period. The 1999 tax levy wilF be approximately $115,588, which is
$62,486 less than anticipated.
i
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 7
Mr. Ron Langness of Springsted, :Inc. recommended authorization of the two
bond issues, stating the bids will be presented at the April 20th City Council
meeting.
98.59 Motion was made by Sindt, seconded by Mulvihill to approve Resolution No.
98-42 authorizing the issuance and sale. of $2,495,000 General Obligation Tax
Increment Bonds, Series 1998A.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt.
98.60 Motion was made by Sindt, seconded by Mulvihill to approve Resolution No.
98-43 authorizing the issuance and sale of $515,000 General Obligation
Equipment Certificates of Indebtedness, Series 19986.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Holberg, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill.
Mayor Zaun recessed the Council meeting at 8:38 p.m. and reconvened at
8:52 p.m.
ITEMS 12-13
Pastor Bill Bohline of Hosanna! Lutheran Church requested. Council approval of
a conditional use permit amendment to allow.the construction of an addition
onto the existing church located at 9600 - 163rd Street. West. He provided an
historic backdrop of the congregation, which is very young and growing rapidly.
A Task Force on Growth was formed and has projected over 4,000 members
by the Year.2000. They had experienced space problems at the former site on
Maple. Island Road and purchased the 22-acre site on Ipava Avenue and
County Road 46 in 1992. From the first inquiry about the site, he stated, they
knew there would be commercial development to the north, probably with a
motor fuel station. The City had required that they build 163rd Street, directly
across from the southern access to Crystal Lake Elementary School. Outlot A
was created as a result of the placement of the road. In 1997, another building
committee was formed in anticipation of acquiring 36 acres to the west for an
addition to their facility and development of a Church Youth Center. He stated
that they will be connecting 163rd Street with County Road 46 in concert with
the Winkler group and Yocum Properties, LLC, and are asking that they be
able to sell Outlot A to the Yocum group. In closing, he stated they have had a
strong working relationship with the Winkler and Yocum groups.
Mr. Sobota provided historical context of the development in this area in
relation to zoning and land uses. Theproperty was zoned for commercial
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 8
development. in 1974, prior to construction of the Crystal Lake Elementary
School Due to the fact that the School District needed additional land when the
school was built, Ipava Avenue was shifted to the west at that location. As a
part of the Crystal Lake Elementary School site acquisition, an agreement was
reached with the Winkler Group to rezone the property to B-4. By 1990,
Crystal Lake Elementary School had been constructed, and this area remained
B-4 zoning. In 1993, a study was conducted and recommended motor fuel and
convenience stores be allowed in the B-2 District by conditional use permit.
The property owner accepted the down-zone of the easterly one-third of the
property from B-4 to B-2 based on the zoning ordinance amendment.
Subsequently, the zoning ordinance requirements pertaining to convenience
stores with gasoline sales and/or car washes were amended in 1997 following
a nine month moratorium. Yocum Oil is the first facility to be processed under
the newly adopted Fuel Facilities Study. Ordinances were upgraded with
regard to minimum lot area, architectural standards, canopy height and facia
limited to 36 inches in width, lighting required inside the canopy, which reduces
glare to the neighborhood, limited signage, drainage from the fuel facility
through an oil and water separator, landscaped area required. to be 25% of the
lot, exterior lighting limitations, no public address system, no outside storage,.
monument sign no taller than 15 feet, and the hours of operation restricted to 5
a.m. to 11 p.m. The purpose of the conditional use permit, Mr. Sobota
explained, is to determine whether the applicant has complied with the
established requirements.
Mr. Tim Yocum, Yocum Oil. Company, presented their proposal for a
convenience store and motor fuel facility, a.k.a. Ipava Marketplace.. He talked
about the affects of Lakeville's moratorium on motor fuel facilities, which, have
forced them to change how they do business. They are a family owned
business and have a strong. reputation for high quality facilities. They have
other stores in neighborhood settings in Maplewood, Inver Grove Heights,
Cottage Grove, Eagan and Jordan. He stated they have either met or
exceeded all City ordinances with regard to this project.
Mr. Tony Yocum addressed the issues that were expressed by area residents
at the Planning Commission's public hearing., specifically the tatement that
this facility will bring traffic from greater distances outside the immediate area.
He explained that in a neighborhood store, 86% of the customers will typically
either work or live within a one mile radius of the facility, thereby capturing the:
traffic that is already there. In response to concerns regarding delivery of
gasoline to the site, they-have agreed to delivery of motor fuel only between
the hours of 3:00 p.m. and 7:30 a.m., which are non-school hours. He
explained that the EPA has set high standards for petroleum facilities, including
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 9
retail facilities, in relation to environmental control, and their facilities either
meet or exceed those standards. He stated there will be security cameras in
the store and car wash, and outdoor cameras to monitor the front parking area
as an additional measure of security. He further stated that Texaco is a major
sponsor of Child Watch, a national organization that identifies finger prints for
children, and they plan to have a Child Watch program set up in all their stores.
Mr. Dempsey provided an overview of the application of Hosanna! Lutheran
Church for an expansion to their existing building at 9600 - 163' Street,
including the extension of 163' Street. The Planning Commission
recommended approval of the conditional use permit subject to eighteen
stipulations.
Mr. Dempsey then provided an overview of the application of Yocum Oil
Company for the preliminary and final plat of Ipava Marketplace Addition,
conditional use permit to allow the construction of a convenience store with
motor fuel sales and car wash, and the vacation of a drainage and utility
easement. He explained that access to the site will be from 163rd Street and a
right-in and right-out on Ipava Avenue. A north-south street connection will be
constructed between 163rd Street and County Road 46 on the west side of
Outlot A, Ipava Marketplace, which will be a right-in and right-out only. The
Planning Commission recommended approval of the proposed preliminary and
..final plat, conditional use permit and. easement vacation with a number of
stipulations. Yocum Oil Company has submitted revised plans which comply
with all. staff and Planning Commission recommendations. Mr. Dempsey stated
the proposed Ipava Marketplace preliminary and final plat and Yocum Oil
Company conditional use permit meet the requirements of the zoning
ordinance and comprehensive plan. Staff recommends approval...
City Engineer Keith Nelson presented a resolution approving plans and
specifications and setting a bid date for the widening of Ipava Avenue on the
west side from 165th Street to County Road 46. Improvements include the
widening of Ipava Avenue to provide for two left turn lanes for northbound
traffic, a northbound right turn lane, two through southbound lanes and a
concrete median. He explained that according to ISD 194 officials, school
busses at Crystal Lake Elementary School utilize the south entrance, and they
are not opposed to the median.
Mayor Zaun opened the meeting to questions or comments from the audience.
Ken Kossack, 16139 Inverness Way, voiced concern with regard to semi
delivery of fuel to the store, pointing out that children don't get out of school.
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 10
until after 3 p.m. He asked why the site is appropriate for a convenience store
if it was not a good location for a liquor store. He asked who is going to pay for
the extension of 163rd Street, and he asked about the exact height of the
proposed median on Ipava Avenue. He also expressed concern with Yocum's
plan to sell Baskin Robbins ice cream at the convenience store, which will
create an additional attraction to children.
John Peterson, 9140 163rd Street West, expressed concern with children
walking to school and the increased traffic this facility will create.
Barb Ryan, 16140 Ingelwood Drive, expressed concerns regarding increased
traffic, hours of operation of the convenience store, and safety of children
walking to school
David Markowitz, 9137 161St Street West, expressed concern regarding safety
of children and the potential for increased .crime and. gang activity in the area
because of the convenience store.
Lacey Cobb, 161.52 Interlachen Boulevard, expressed concern regarding
safety of children who attend Crystal Lake Elementary School
Rich WendorFf, 16200 Inglewood Drive, asked if there was a needs analysis
done for this area with regard to a gas station. He stated it is a well known fact
throughout the metro area that gang members are using convenience stores to
recruit children. He also stated there are. special education busses that use the
north driveway at Crystal Lake Elementary School
Debbie Cobb, 16152 Interlachen Boulevard, expressed concern regarding
safety of children who have to walk to and from school because they are not
bussed. She felt that parents will no longer want their children walking to
school, which will cause more motor vehicle traffic congestion at the school
She felt that the parking spaces at the convenience store, which will face the
school, will serve as a place for child abductors to sit and watch children at the
school
Jack Akenson, 10075 161St Street, stated he felt the Yocum project is a .good
one; however, he feels they are putting it in the wrong location.. He pointed out
that there will be other vehicles besides gasoline trucks making frequent
deliveries to the convenience store. He felt that children will be buying junk
food, pop and tobacco at this convenience store,. further stating he sees minors
buying tobacco almost daily at the Kwik Trip and SuperAmerica on Kenrick
Avenue. He stated that if the Council votes in favor of this convenience store,
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 11
the. City will be held accountable. He also addressed Pastor Bohline, asking
him to reconsider his position on this matter.
Becky Peterson, 9140 163~d Street West, expressed concern regarding safety
of children.
Glenn Sayer, .16135 Inglewood Drive, asked questions regarding the size of
gas price signs, hours of operation and fuel delivery and whether these would
be made a part of the conditional use permit.
Tim Wheatley, 16435 Iris Court, expressed concern regarding gas stations
near schools. He asked if motorists will be able to take a left turn out of Crystal
Lake Elementary. He also asked what happens when a convenience store
goes out of business.
98.61 Motion was made by Sindt, seconded by Mulvihill to extend the Council
meeting beyond the 10:30 adjournment time.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg.
The City Council considered the appropriateness of tabling Items 12 and 13 to
allow time for staff and Yocum Oil representatives to address the questions
raised by the residents.
Mr. Erickson stated that due to the time lines required .under State law, the
applicants would have to agree to the Council tabling a decision on these
items.
Mr. Tarell Friedley, attorney for Hosanna! Lutheran Church, stated they would
not be willing to consent to tabling their item until the next Council meeting.
The City Council asked the City-Attorney if the Hosanna! matter could be acted
on if the Ipava Marketplace matter is tabled. Mr. Knutson recommended that
since the Hosanna! Lutheran Church and lpava Marketplace items are inter-
related with regard to the access off of County Road 46, property changing
hands and platting, they should be considered together.
In response to a question from the audience, Councilmember Sindt stated the
Yocum site had never, to her knowledge, been considered by the City for a
liquor store. She asked if the convenience store will be limiting the number of
children allowed in the store atone time. Mr. Yocum stated they do not permit
loitering inside or outside their stores.
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 12
Councilmember Mulvihill clarified that Ipava Avenue has always been
scheduled to be a main north/south corridor (high density minor
arterial/parkway) and is not being widened just because of this development.
She stated she feels confident that Mr. Yocum will adhere to the fuel delivery
hours during non-school hours, whatever those hours may be. She stated it is
unfortunate that citizens had to state their-cases regarding the safety oftheir
children with certain threats or innuendoes. She explained that the role of the
City Council is to determine whether the application meets the requirements of
the City's zoning ordinance and not whether there is a market demand for
another gas station. She stated she is very in tune with what is going on with
the gang culture and doesn't personally feel there is a .major concern with
convenience stores recruiting children to gangs, pointing out that it can happen
just as easily in schools and parks. She asked the Chief of Police if there have
been problems or increase in crime with the Kwik Trip and McDonald's on
Dodd Boulevard in relation to their proximity to Lake Marion Elementary
School Chief Martens stated that in anticipation of this question, the Police
Department researched the calls from that area and found nothing remarkable
due to the location of the convenience store or McDonald's near the
elementary school
Mr. Erickson explained that the primary element of the parkway section on
Ipava Avenue is to control speed and maintain a high level of aesthetics in the
adjoining residential neighborhoods. He pointed out that in order for the City to
get Federal and State funding for the County Road 46 interchange, the project
was approved with the condition that Ipava Avenue be extended from County
Road 46 to Highway 50.
.Councilmember Ryan asked about the number of lanes proposed for Ipava
Avenue and the number of turn lanes off of County Road 46 to 163rd Street.
Mr. Nelson stated Co. Rd. 46 has five lanes of traffic with six to eight foot
shoulders. Ipava Avenue wilt also have. five lanes with no shoulders. Mr.
Erickson stated City staff contacted the School District and Schmitty & Sons
Bus Company, who both indicated that they have no concerns with the change
in the roadway.
Councilmember Ryan asked the Chief of Police to comment regarding the
negative affects of a convenience store being located near an elementary
school
Chief Martens stated he was not sure where the residents were getting
information regarding crime at convenience stores, but it is not coming. from the
CITY OF GAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 13
Lakeville Police Department. He stated he does not know of a single gang
recruitment at a convenience store or of a single child that has been stalked by
a pedophile at a convenience store. He stated the Lakeville stores are in
compliance with local ordinances regarding the sale of tobacco to minors. He
pointed out that a larger problem they have is with adults buying. cigarettes and
selling them to minors, which is how three-quarters of the children are getting
cigarettes.
Mr. Erickson explained that the City is only paying for moving of the signal on
County Road 46, construction of the median and the extra. left turn lane, which
is being done as a result of increasing levels of traffic unrelated to this
development. He further explained that the height of the median will be
consistent with others in the city.
Mayor Zaun explained that no conditional use permit would have been needed
had this been just a convenience store. The conditional use permit is required
only for a motor fuel. facility and car wash, which allows the City to attach
conditions. He cited recent court case rulings in other cities where
convenience stores were denied due to neighborhood protest. The fact that
community members oppose the land owner using his land for a particular
purpose is not legally sufficient reason for denying a conditional use permit. He
urged parents to share in the responsibility of keeping the. area safe. He stated
he has concerns for traffic in that area and would propose that a thorough
traffic analysis be done prior to any future commercial development adjacent to
this property.
Mr. Erickson stated the Dakota County traffic engineer witnessed a very
dangerous situation near Crystal Lake Elementary School whereby children
were not using the pedestrian crossing and running across County Road 46.
The traffic engineer will be sending a letter to Superintendent Wahlstrom
indicating it may be necessary to provide adult crossing guards at this location.
He also indicated that the County will install advance warning signs
immediately.
Mayor Zaun asked if the school district has a policy to provide bussing for
students across County Road 46. Mr. Erickson stated according to information
he received from the school district, bussing is available.
Mayor Zaun suggested a school speed zone sign be posted north of 165th
Street near the school for motorists traveling north on Ipava Avenue..
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 14
Mr. Dempsey responded to the question regarding the size of gas price signs,
which are limited to 16 square feet.
Councilmember Holberg explained that regardless of what happens with this
proposal, the safety issue on County Road 46 and Ipava Avenue needs to be
addressed. Improvements are driven by the traffic that is already there. She
also felt that there are safety issues that need to be dealt with at the school
district level. It is ironic,. she stated, that the commercial zoning at this corner
occurred as the result of a land trade tha# made Crystal Lake Elementary
School possible. She pointed out that Lakeville has the toughest standards for
convenience stores in the metro area, and Yocum Oil has met all those
standards.. She stated she cannot personally identify a legally defensible way
to vote against this application and would not want to waste taxpayers money
in court.
Councilmember Ryan acknowledged the petitions and phone. calls received
from the residents. He stated he agrees with Councilmember Holberg, except.
he is convinced this area can live without another gas station. However, the
facts are stacked up in favor of Yocum Oil, which is an excellent company, and
he stated he personally looks forward to using this facility. He voiced his
concern over the traffic problems on County Road 46 and Ipava Avenue, but
stated he is convinced that the increased traffic flows and congestion will be
lessened by the systems before the Council this evening.
.Councilmember Mulvihill. explained that the marketing strategy is a risk that
Yocum Oil has to take. The City Council is not in a position to determine that
strategy. She stated she feels there is no way the Council can deny the
application.
Councilmember Sindt stated she feels it is the responsibility of parents to teach
their children what is appropriate, and they need to be taught that it is not
appropriate to walk across County Road 46 at that particular location.
Mayor Zaun indicated he would like to add a couple conditions to the
conditional use permit. One would involve the motor fuel delivery times. A
suggestion was made to only allow fuel delivers between 7 p.m. and 6 a.m.
Mr. Yocum agreed to that. condition. Mayor Zaun also suggested a condition
be added requiring .posting of directional signs on the commercial site.
Since the two projects are inter-related, the City Attorney recommended that
the City Council act on Items 12 and 13 in one motion.
•
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 15
98.62 Motion was made by Sindt, seconded by ..Mulvihill to receive the Planning
Commission's Findings of .Fact and Recommendation and approve a
conditional use permit amendment for Hosanna! Lutheran Church to allow the
construction of an addition onto the existing church located at 9600-163rd
Street West; and receive the Planning Commission's Findings of Fact and
Recommendation. and approve Resolution No. 98-44 vacating a drainage and
utility easement, Resolution No. 98-45 approving the preliminary and final plat
of Ipava Marketplace; a conditional use permit to allow the construction and
operation of a convenience store, gasoline station and car wash south of
County Road 46 and west of Ipava Avenue, including two additional conditions
prohibiting motor fuel deliveries between the hours of 6:00 a.m. and 7 p.m. and
requiring the installation of .directional signage on the site to .guide on-site traffic
toward north-bound Ipava Avenue; and Resolution No. 98-46 approving plans
and specifications and setting a bid date for Ipava Avenue widening from 165th
Street to County Road 46, Improvement Project 98-9.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg. Nays,
Ryan. Councilmember Ryan stated he feels the City does not need another
gas station.
. Mayor Zaun recessed the meeting. at 11:50 p.m. and reconvened at 11:58 p.m.
98.63 Motion was made by Sindt, seconded by Mulvihill to direct staff to meet with
ISD 194 officials regarding its current bussing policy for Crystal Lake
Elementary School and further~discuss pedestrian safety issues for the County
Road 46 and Ipava Avenue crossings.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan., Zaun.
98.64 Motion was made by Holberg, seconded by Mulvihill to direct that a traffic study
be prepared prior to the issuance of a building permit for future commercial.
development on the property west of Ipava Avenue.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt.
ITEM 14
Mr. Nelson presented the proposed 1998-2002 Capital Improvement Plan and
highlighted some of the more significant projects proposed. (See Capital
Improvement Pian, 1998-2002, dated March, 1998, on file in the City Clerk's
office. )
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
.MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 16
Mr. Feller reviewed the primary funding sources for the projects described in
the CIP as follows: special assessments to benefiting properties, public works
reserve fund, storm sewer trunk fund, water trunk fund, sanitary sewer trunk
fund, park and trail dedication fund and other revenue anticipated from the
State and County in conjunction with signalization of major intersections. Three
projects are proposed to be financed with the issuance of state aid revenue
bonds. They are Pilot Knob Road from County Road 46 to 170th Street,
County Road 46 from Pilot Knob to, TH 52 and Cedar Avenue from Dodd to
County Road 70. Permanent bonds will be issued in 2000 to refinance the
temporary bonds issued in 1997. Lakeville's per capita debt is expected to
decrease at a steady rate over the next five years to $915 per capita in the
year 2002.
Mr. Feller explained that the CIP includes a list of "non-programmed" projects
which will not be undertaken unless the CIP is revised by the City Council
These projects are primarily for new infrastructure improvements and will be
monitored until such time as they are deemed necessary to,proceed with
implementation. If any of the "non-programmed" projects are approved. during
the next five years, the City will need to issue debt to finance construction..
Zaun asked what the City's per capita debt was in 1997, Dennis stated it was
approximately $1,200 per capita.
Councilmember Ryan pointed out that the new urbanism study was not to be
included in the 1998 budget. Mr. Erickson stated that item. is not included in
the CIP and should have been deleted from Mr. Feller's cover memo dated
March 13, 1998. Mr. Feller will make the correction.
98.65 Motion was made by Mulvihill, seconded by Holberg to approve Resolution No.
98-47 adopting a Capital Improvement Program for 1998-2002.
Roll call was taken on the motion.. Ayes, Holberg, .Ryan, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill.
ITEM 15
Mr. Sobota presented a proposed ordinance amending Section 45 of the
zoning ordinance concerning the Floodplain Overlay District. He stated the
.ordinance amendment is required due to the revisions to the Flood Insurance
Rate Map and the Flood Insurance Study for Lakeville initiated by the City and
recently approved by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).
The revisions were requested because recent City improvements to the storm
sewer system have eliminated potential flood impacts in various areas of the
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 17
i
.City. The Planning Commission recommended approval of the ordinance
amendment.
98.66 Motion was made by Sindt, seconded by Mulvihill to adopt Ordinance No. 625
amending Section 45 of the Lakeville Zoning Ordinance concerning the
Floodplain Overlay District.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg.
ITEMS 7A and 7M
Councilmember Ryan stated there is a payment on the check register to BCM
Construction for the Boulder Village 1st Addition. He asked abouf the status of
.this project and status with regard to default. Mr. Feller explained that the City
drew upon the letter of credit for Boulder 1st Addition and immediately
proceeded to pay the delinquent taxes and special assessments against the
parcels in the project, as well as the delinquent accounts receivable. There
was sufficient money in the letter of credit to pay off the amount due to the
primary contractor, BCM Construction, which was a condition of the
development contract. Mr. Knutson added that payment would be subject to
release of a mechanics .lien. Mr. feller stated there is still $161,952 in escrow
from the letter of creditto pay any additional obligations on the project.
98.67. Motion was made by Holberg, seconded by Sindt to approve the claims for
payment and final acceptance of public utilities and street improvement of
Innsbrook Drive in Boulder Village 1st Addition.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan.
ITEM 7G
Councilmember Ryan asked for an explanation of this program. Mr. Hennen
provided an .overview of the community clean-up day, scheduled for April 18,
1998, and the collection of household hazardous waste at the park
maintenance building as part of clean-up day. Mr. Erickson stated he and Mr.
Hennen met with Dakota County officials and suggested a joint venture wi#h
the cities of Burnsville and Apple Valley for two collection dates of household
hazardous waste in each community, now that the Aptus site is no longer.
available for monthly collection.
i
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 18
98.68 Motion was made by Holberg, seconded by Mulvihill to approve a Joint Powers
Agreement between the County of Dakota and the City of Lakeville for
household hazardous waste. collection on April 18, 1998.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan, Zaun.
ITEM 7Q
Councilmember Holberg asked about the process, time line and selection of a
team leader and whether the selection will be made by the City or County. Mr.
Erickson stated staff will contact Charlotte Shover of the Dakota County
Environmental Education Program, and the information will be forwarded to the
Council at the next work session.
98.69 Motion was made by Holberg, seconded by Sindtto table consideration of the
City's participation in the Dakota County Environmental Education Wetland
Evaluation Project until the April 6th Council meeting.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Mulvihill, Holberg, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt.
ITEM 16
98.70 Motion .was made by Sindt, seconded by Mulvihill to set a Council work session
for Wednesday, April 1St at 6:00 p.m.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Holberg, Ryan, .Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill
UNFINISHED BUSINESS None
NEW BUSINESS
Mr. Erickson provided information regarding recent decisions by Frontier
Communications and US West Communications to delineate service
.boundaries according to service provider telephone exchange boundaries
rather than corporate community boundaries. As a result, approximately 800
Lakeville residents would be required to .use the new 615 area code. He
recommended that a letter be sent to the Minnesota Public Utilities
Commission urging the Commission to uphold its previous decision. and
maintain the original boundaries that would leave the entire community of
Lakeville in the 612 area code.
CITY OF LAKEVILLE COUNCIL MEETING
MARCH 16, 1998
PAGE 19
•
98.71 Motion was made by Mulvihill seconded by Sindt to authorize Mayor Zaun to
send a letter urging the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission to uphold its
original decision to require division of the telephone area codes along
corporate community boundaries.
Roll call was taken on the motion. Ayes, Ryan, Zaun, Sindt, Mulvihill, Holberg.
ANNOUNCEMENTS: .Next regular Council meeting, April 6, 1998
Special Council meeting, April 7, 1998
Council work session, March 18, 1998
Mayor Zaun adjourned the meeting at 12:47 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Charlene Friedges, C' Clerk
Du ne Zaun, Ma or